Is It True That "Out of a Thousand Reciters, Only One or Two Are Reborn"? | Master Jingben
【Q&A Series】
Is It True That "Out of a Thousand Reciters, Only One or Two Are Reborn"?
But there is a question that has long troubled me: among modern Pure Land practitioners, some appear very diligent, even sustaining their practice for decades, for a whole lifetime — and yet they do not seem to have been successfully reborn in the Pure Land. Some even say that out of a thousand reciters, only one or two are reborn. Why would this be?
Master Shan-dao said: "When sentient beings call the Name, they are certain to be reborn." He also said that even when the mouth recites Amitabha while the mind is scattered, this still works — Amitabha will still grant blessing and embrace the practitioner. And Master, you yourself have taught: "We do not board Amitabha Buddha's Vow-Ship only at the moment of death — when we recite the Name in this life, we are already aboard." Then why do these practitioners not reach the destination? Did they jump ship halfway? Kindly request Master's compassionate and detailed answer.
Master Jingben Answers: Namo Amitabha Buddha. This is a wonderful question, and I believe it is a doubt that troubles many Pure Land practitioners.
1. Who says they were not reborn?
First, let us ask one question: who says those reciters of the Name were not reborn? Rebirth is a matter between Amitabha Buddha and the practitioner. With our ordinary mortal eyes, we have no way to judge whether another person has been reborn or not. We must not conclude that someone was not reborn simply because we did not see auspicious signs or hear heavenly music. The absence of auspicious signs does not mean the absence of rebirth — this point is very important.
2. "Out of a thousand, only one or two are reborn" has no scriptural basis
This saying was not spoken by the Buddha, nor by Master Shan-dao, nor is it found in any sutra or treatise. In fact, this saying directly contradicts Amitabha Buddha's Original Vow. The 18th Vow makes it perfectly clear: sentient beings of the ten directions, so long as they recite the Name, are certain to be reborn.
3. What did Master Shan-dao say?
Master Shan-dao stated very clearly: "When sentient beings call the Name, they are certain to be reborn." "Certain" means without exception. The power of Amitabha Buddha's Vow is true and unfailing — this is beyond doubt.
Then why do some who recite the Name still seem uncertain of their rebirth? The problem is not with Amitabha — it is with the practitioner. Some recite the Name with their mouth, yet do not truly believe that recitation can bring rebirth. They imagine that rebirth must be terribly difficult, that everything depends on their own efforts to be saved, and they grow excessively worried — about their heavy karmic obstacles, about their recitation not being pure enough, about their practice not being good enough. As a result, the more they recite, the less confident they become — and finally they lose heart and give up. This is the true obstacle.
Master Shan-dao also clearly stated: "Those who practice exclusively [the Name] — of ten, ten will be reborn; of a hundred, a hundred. But those who practice mixed methods without wholehearted devotion — out of a thousand, not one." This means: those who exclusively recite the Name "Namo Amitabha Buddha" — ten out of ten are reborn, a hundred out of a hundred, not one is left behind. But for those who practice many different methods — reciting the Name today, switching to another Dharma practice tomorrow, so that recitation is no longer their single, exclusive practice — out of a thousand, not one reaches rebirth.
Master Shan-dao further said: "The Land of Ultimate Bliss is the unconditioned realm of Nirvana; through scattered virtues and mixed practices, rebirth is hard to attain. Therefore the Tathagata selected the essential method, teaching us to recite Amitabha, exclusively, ever exclusively." If one practices many methods according to one's own preference, rebirth becomes difficult. Therefore Shakyamuni Tathagata especially selected for us the most essential method — teaching us to recite Amitabha, and to do so exclusively, ever exclusively. This is not to belittle other Dharma practices, but because recitation of the Name is the practice that most perfectly resonates with Amitabha's Vow-Power.
So the question is never whether Amitabha's Vow-Power is sufficient — it is whether we ourselves take refuge in it exclusively, rely upon it exclusively, and call the Name with exclusive devotion.
Your "jump ship" analogy is in fact very apt — it is not that the ship is unstable, nor that the ship cannot reach the other shore. Rather, it is that some hearts cannot settle — one moment thinking this ship is not big enough, the next moment wanting to switch to another ship, jumping back and forth, and so never arriving. So long as we sit peacefully aboard Amitabha's Vow-Ship and call the Name with exclusive devotion, we will certainly reach the other shore of Ultimate Bliss — without any mishap.
Please recite the Name with a peaceful heart, and do not be shaken by sayings that have no basis. Amitabha Buddha's vow, "should they fail to be born there, may I not attain perfect enlightenment," is our most stable refuge for rebirth. Master Shan-dao's words are the assurance that settles our heart: when sentient beings call the Name, they are certain to be reborn.
If it would help, you may also listen to past Dharma teachings that have been shared. I trust they will deepen your understanding in this area, and your faith in recitation will grow ever firmer. Namo Amitabha Buddha
微信分享
扫描二维码，或复制链接分享
